Jyoti CNC automation debuts on bourses with modest gains, analysts remain cautious

Some analysts pointed towards the higher valuation demanded by the IPO as a potential concern. The issue was priced at the upper end of the band at ₹331 per share, raising ₹1,000 crore.

Shares of Jyoti CNC Automation made a lukewarm debut on the bourses today, listing with a premium of around 12% against the issue price. The stock opened at ₹370 on the National Stock Exchange (NSE) and ₹372 on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), surpassing analysts’ predictions of a listing between ₹360 and ₹380 per share.

Despite the positive debut, analysts cautioned against excessive optimism, advising investors to adopt a wait-and-watch approach. They highlighted the company’s relatively lower profitability and the competitive landscape within the CNC automation space as factors for their cautious stance.

The IPO, which closed on January 11, 2024, received a strong response from investors, being subscribed a commendable 38.53 times overall. Retail investors and non-institutional investors (NIIs) contributed significantly to the subscription success, with the retail portion being fully booked within the first 30 minutes of opening.

However, some analysts pointed towards the higher valuation demanded by the IPO as a potential concern. The issue was priced at the upper end of the band at ₹331 per share, raising ₹1,000 crore. This, coupled with the competitive market and Jyoti CNC’s smaller size compared to established players, has prompted analysts to recommend a cautious approach towards the stock.

Jyoti CNC Automation’s market position on January 16, 2024, was quite dynamic and saw significant movement after its listing debut. Here’s a breakdown:

Market Debut:

  • Opened at ₹370 on NSE and ₹372 on BSE, indicating an 11.8% and 12.4% premium over the issue price of ₹331, respectively.
  • This surpassed analyst predictions of a listing between ₹360 and ₹380 per share.
  • However, analysts maintained a cautious stance due to potential concerns like lower profitability and a competitive market.

Intraday Performance:

  • The stock continued to climb throughout the day, reaching a high of ₹410.6 per share on NSE and ₹412.75 on BSE.
  • This translates to a gain of over 24% from its opening price and a remarkable 41% premium over the issue price.
  • Overall, it was a strong performance for the newly listed stock.

Closing Market Position:

  • Jyoti CNC Automation closed at ₹402 per share on NSE and ₹403.1 per share on BSE.
  • This represents a gain of 21.45% and 21.78% respectively, compared to the issue price.
  • While it saw some moderation from its intraday high, it still retained a significant premium on its listing.

Volume and Market Sentiment:

  • The stock witnessed impressive trading volume, indicating strong investor interest and participation.
  • Analyst opinions remained mixed, with some recommending caution while others acknowledging the positive debut and potential for future growth.


However, based on Jyoti CNC Automation’s current position and the general market trends, here are some potential scenarios for the company’s future:


Positive Outlook:

  • Robust growth: The Indian CNC machine market is expected to grow significantly in the coming years, fueled by factors like increased automation adoption, government initiatives, and growing domestic demand.
  • Improved profitability: The company’s profitability has been modest in the past, but strong future performance could lead to improved margins and return on investments. This, in turn, could attract more investors and boost the stock price.
  • Expansion and diversification: Jyoti CNC Automation is focused on expanding its product portfolio and geographical reach. Successful execution of these plans could enhance the company’s competitive advantage and open up new avenues for growth.


Challenges and Concerns:

    • Competition: The CNC machine market is highly competitive, with established players like Siemens, Mazak, and DMG Mori controlling a significant market share. Jyoti CNC Automation needs to differentiate itself with unique offerings and competitive pricing to stand out.
    • Macroeconomic risks: Global economic headwinds or slowdowns in the Indian economy could impact the demand for CNC machines, affecting Jyoti CNC Automation’s sales and profitability.
    • Valuation concerns: The IPO was priced at the upper end of the band, raising concerns about potential overvaluation. If the company does not meet future growth expectations, the stock price might face downward pressure.